In the case of Mexico, an experience
was begun in 1995 by the Occupational Competency Standardisation
and Certification Council (CONOCER), the most important initiative
with the greatest scope in the field of occupational competencies
in the region. It was an answer to interest on the part of the
Government in achieving the participation, among other mechanisms,
of the players, by stimulating demand with the aim of supporting
the design and development of training based on competency standards
and their certification.
The occupational competency system which has
been applied includes the following main components:
To define technical occupational competency standards by
branch of activity or occupational group, to be implemented
by the social partners with governmental support.
To establish mechanisms for evaluation, verification and
certification of knowledge, abilities and skills of individuals,
regardless of the way in which they have been acquired, providing
they meet technical competency standards.
To transform the supply of training into a flexible modular
system based on competency standards in order that individuals
may move among the modules according to their needs.
To create stimuli to demand, in order to promote the new
system among the population and firms, seeking an equitable
distribution of training and certification opportunities,
and also catering to the needs of the disadvantaged population.
Following the creation of a system of national
coverage, greater stress is laid on the definition of standards
for the more general functions in the different economic branches,
technological languages and occupational areas.
Finally, this initiative is conceived from
the standpoint of finding a valid alternative to link the different
types of education and training with the countrys employment
demands. The challenge is to approach the modernisation of educational
and training -for- labour systems, not only so that they respond
to the exigencies of adaptation to the new conditions of the
economy and technology, but particularly to cater to the need
to make education and training available to all sectors of the
population, with suitable and relevant content and with the
quality required by the labour market. At present there are
45 Labour Competency Standardisation Committees operating in
Mexico, 57 pilot projects are being carried out in firms of
different sectors of economic activity to foster skill development
and training of individuals, and seven certifying bodies and
nine Evaluation Centres have been accredited. On 13 December
last, the first 120 Labour Competency Certificates were distributed.
The Directing Board of the INA of Costa Rica
decided in 1997 to include the standardisation and certification
of occupational skills in its institutional policy. To that
end, its started a project for applying the competencies approach
in the Tourism sector, with technical assistance provided by
the ILO International Training Centre at Turin.
Upon completion of the scheme the INA has modular vocational
training programmes in the catering and lodging subsectors for
the following occupations: Hotel Cooks Assistant, Hotel
Cook, Receptionist, Waiter and Bartender. The INA devised a
methodological process for the development of the relevant skills
standards.
To apply the modular system, the following
criteria were followed: flexibility, by offering several certifiable
occupational outlets; adaptability, multi-functionality, integrity,
dynamism and compliance with the paradigm "Education/training
for Productive work".
The INA has also laid down methodological procedures for
the development of skills standards in general and the modularisation
of such standards; for the curricular design of modular units
and training modules. It has also established a procedure for
labour certification on the basis of occupational skills.
The Costa Rican Institute has further implemented a Teachers
Training Project based on occupational competency standards.
This scheme had the following aim: "Formulating modular
training programmes for the training of instructors, on the
basis of occupational competencies, for use at the INA itself
and at the National Vocational Education System (Spanish acronym:
SNFP)".
For that purpose, an educators job profile was defined
and validated; relevant occupational standards were established
and modular programmes were devised for the training of teachers
for the INA and the SNFP.
Some of the reasons for this initiative were:
a) There is a present a great shortage of instructors trained
in the design and delivery of Vocational Training programmes.
b) There is no institution in the country to train educators
with the job profile required.
c) The INA, governing body of the National Vocational Education
System, is in charge of training instructors in accordance with
current demands and requirements of the labour market.
d) Instructors training programmes
have to take into account current changes in educational technology,
in particular those regarding training based on occupational
skills.
e) Experience has shown that the teaching-learning process
requires educators with the necessary skills to ensure adequate
training.
In Uruguay, the National Employment Bureau (DINAE),
with the co-operation of the IDB, is carrying out a project
to study, design and prepare the implementation of a standardisation,
training and certification system in occupational competencies.
To do so, the project is planning to establish a single register
of training bodies and is working on four large areas: a comparative
survey of competency systems developed in other countries in
order to determine whether they can be implemented in Uruguay;
information and training activities involving all the players
in society; development of pilot experiences of competency standardisation
in different economic sectors; design of a technical proposal
and possible strategies for the implementation of a National
Competencies System.
Moreover, in the same country, an exhaustive educational
reform has been under way since 1995, structured on the coordinates
of a search for equity and quality upgrading. In vocational-technical
education, the reform proposes to achieve coherent interconnected
and high quality technical and technological education, which,
as well as attending to its specific tasks (to provide efficient
and multivalent training to co-operate with the transformation
of productive structures and improve the living conditions of
workers), dovetails with and complements Secondary Education
in an effort to provide the population with thourough basic
and mid-level education. With this aim, the Technical-Vocational
Education Council (CETP-UTU) is restructuring and re-formulating
the education it supplies, the main novelties being the implementation
of the Basic Technological Cycle and the Technological Secondary
School Certificate. The former is divided into two areas: agricultural
and technical, and it proposes to internalise technological
culture in adolescents and develop competencies on which a later
and complementary, broader and more modern, vocational option
may be based. The technological secondary school curricula,
three years in duration, with the double aim of being an instance
of final mid-level education and granting a Technical Assistant
certificate, are designed to be the intellectual, technical
and manual ability base providing interdisciplinary and cross-sectional
content and approaches, around an organising core or nucleus
responding to the main fields of development of the national
economy and structured around occupational families. Thus, in
1997, the following disciplines were implemented: Industrial
and Basic Chemistry, Thermodynamics, Data Processing and Maintenance,
Administration and Services, and Agricultural Technology. The
secondary school certificates make possible either entry into
university or continuation of technical specialisation studies,
in the CETP itself, seeking thus to attend to the training of
mid-level and higher technicians according to the training demands
of the productive sectors.
The aims of this reform are very explicit regarding
developing in young people a solid general education, well grounded
in science and technology and with the knowledge, abilities
and skills which will allow them to be flexible and adapt quickly
to change and to life-long learning. The starting point is a
conception of Uruguay as a small country in the process of development
and inserted in a world subject to constant economic, scientific
and technological change. The belief is that the educational
challenge involves preparing its human resources and its economy
for a life of uncertainty. It is thus believed that the symbolic
languages to be grasped thouroughly go beyond the capacity to
express oneself and communicate orally and in writing, and include
computer science, telematics, foreign languages and critical
evaluation of audiovisual messages. Also indispensable are a
mastery of scientific methods and knowledge in order to understand,
interpret and handle natural and social phenomena; acquirement
of mathematical competencies to acquire methodology and mastery
of strategies for identifying problems and solving them; and
a change in socio-historical competencies from the standpoint
that cultural boundaries and world geography are becoming imprecise
and satellite communications modify information-handling radically.
And, last but not least, it is necessary to acquire a technological
culture that facilitates the integration of youth into the world
of production and labour and their understanding of its technical
and social dimensions.
Taking as a basis SENAIs Mission,
i.e. "Contributing to the strengthening of industry
and to the full and sustainable development of the country,
promoting education for work and civic responsibility, technical
and technological assistance, production and the dissemination
of knowledge, adaptation and circulation of technology",
and the Institutes Vision of its own future,
namely that "by 2010 SENAI is destined to play a leading
role as internationally recognised. technologically renewed
occupational training body, managed according to results"
its Strategic Plan for the 2000-2010 period establishes
the following guidelines:
Systemic action
Action upon productive chains
Improved management
Market oriented
Social responsibility
Sustainability
The Action Plan that accompanies and enlarges upon the
previous document consists of 34 processes and 49 projects that
aim at the following objectives, among others:
Objective 1: expanding SENAI participation
in the vocational education market, to meet the needs both of
traditional segments and technologically advanced ones.
Among activities foreseen in connection with
this objective are: reviewing and updating curricula and programmes;
promoting 25 new CEMEP certifications; training 150 technicians
to evaluate 1,500 students in a "Knowledge Olympiad",
setting up an occupational information service; implementing
a national distance education programme with 13 courses running
up till late 2002; introducing a follow-up system of SENAI graduates,
and monitoring of former trainees at two Regional Departments.
Objective 3: Offering proactive attention to
customers in the national territory, through co-ordinated, standardised
and personalised services.
Activities contemplated under this rubric include:
developing an integral system of market information based on
a survey of 20,000 firms and enterprises; training 30 market
agents in Regional Departments; introducing a comprehensive
system for the exchange of information through "Infovía",
with the participation of 15 Regional Departments; promoting
personnel development in enterprises of national scope.
Objective 4: Looking after the demands of productive
chains in a systemic, overall manner.
Disseminating and supporting the APPCC system
in the different segments of the food production chain among
3,000 firms, 300 of which are in the export business; drafting
4 small thesauri and 4 glossaries a year to facilitate data
retrieval from productive chains; preparing a half-yearly report
on the evaluation of focal scenarios for previously studied
productive chains; developing 3 business plans for productive
chains; supporting the implementation of 3 projects of overall
attention to productive chains every year; sponsoring the conclusion
of 3 co-operation agreements a year for technological development,
favouring technologically updated services.
Objective 6: Expanding SENAI action with micro
and small enterprises.
Forging links with IEL and SEBRAE to look after
firms of this kind; developing SENAI action strategies for the
different types of incubators and technical development schemes;
helping 200 small industrial firms to modernise their management
models.
Objective 10: achieving excellence in institutional
performance in line with accepted practices of quality management.
Mapping and optimising procedures, systematising
the management model of the National Department; maintaining
ISO 9001:94 standard for the National Department and making
ready for ISO 9001:2000; introducing a system of strategic indicators
of SENAI performance; adopting State SGPE in all Regional Departments
by December 2002 and training 250 new users; consolidating and
expanding occupational certification by setting up at least
one sectoral committee in every Regional Department.
In Brazil, with the opening up of the international
market, the demands for higher product quality levels have increased
and, therefore, for worker qualifications. The Vocational
Training and Development Secretariat (SEFOR) of the Ministry
of Labour, jointly with the ILO, implement a project for
the design of a certification system. The variety of the supply
of training and the interaction of multiple players on a stage
in which training is being carried out not only within the framework
of an "S system" (SENAC, SENAI, SENAR, SENAT) institutional
base but also through a large amount of other private institutions
linked to communities or sectors, generate an environment in
which occupational certification can provide transparency and
facilitate the mobility of workers and the improvement of the
quality of training.
The proposal for the system is considering the multiple
experiences in the area of vocational training which exist and
are operating from nongovernmental organisations, unions and
the "S system." The introduction of the occupational
competency approach is one of the critical aspects of the possible
proposal; in that regard different international models have
been analysed and experiences in Brazilian firms have also been
identified and publicised.
The project has its base in a consulting group in which
representatives of the Government (SEFOR and the Technological
Mid-level Education Secretariat - SEMTEC), of workers (CUT,
Fuerza Sindical, CGT), of the SENAI and of the National Confederation
of Industry (CNI) participate.
This group, supported by external consultants and through
the organisation of various workshops to analyse national and
international experiences, is already studying a proposed certification
scheme. It is expected that the proposal will be completed this
year and, at the same time, some pilot experiences will be developed
and other existing experiences will be documented before formulating
a final design.
A special feature of this experience arises from the participation
of SEMTEC, in an approach to the mid-level technical education
and vocational education proposals. The framework created by
the new Law on Basic Guidelines for Education enabled SEMTEC
to initiate work regarding certification and the introduction
of the competencies approach. The aims from the standpoint of
education and of labour have much in common and joint action
is making possible their alignment.
Another example of integration between the vocational training
system and the higher education system is to be found in Brazil,
with the creation, in 1997, of the Textile Industrial Engineering
Course, through the Chemical and Textile Industry Technology
Centre (CETIQT) of the SENAI of Rio de Janeiro. This innovative
offer aims to train professionals specialised and skilled for
the rapid development of knowledge, for working in multidisciplinary
teams and for exercising leadership focused as enterprising
and management action, as well as for perceiving the importance
of environmental control and for understanding organizations
and business.
The course added to its curriculum some novel aspects:
management, environment, quality, humanities, technical standards,
safety, sociology, politics and legislation. Its creation seeks
to meet the aspirations of textile line employers: from the
rural producer to the manufacturers and distributors, who seek
to modernise and increase productivity and competitiveness in
the sector in the internal and external markets.
A Graphics Technology course was added, in 1998, to the
Textile Industrial Engineering Course. Through the SENAI "Theobaldo
de Nigris" School, in Sao Paulo, this course, also a pioneer
endeavour in Brazil, is to train professionals by solid development
of their scientific and technological skills which will allow
them to take part in the management of production, administration
and business in the graphics area. Lasting three years and with
a workload of 3,200 hours, the project was based on European
and North American models for training graphics engineers. Along
these same lines, the SENAI is preparing to launch new higher
courses in the footwear, paper and food areas.
In Honduras, the Programme of Education for Labour
(POCET) is a Central American example of this alignment between
the regular educational systems, and especially adult education
and training as life-long education. It is one of the first
and richest experiences of integration between traditions among
which historically there was little linkage and, at the same
time, an experience of dialogue of those traditions with the
new debates and paradigms that have involved cross-sectionally
the spheres of education and vocational training, in which the
new ideas regarding life-long education and training should
be specially highlighted. In this case the Ministry of Public
Education of Honduras and the National Vocational Training Institute
(INFOP) have acted in an integrated manner, at the same time
incorporating methodological approaches which are usually only
to be found among nongovernmental organisations.
In this regard, the POCET programme is a central reference
point for a whole tradition established around the principles
of adult education, with its assistance-providing cast and its
orientation towards literacy. POCET signalled the way towards
integration of the contributions made at the time by all those
linked to various forms of popular education with other currents
-such as vocational training- with long experience in the field
of education for productive labour. The latter currents are
also deeply involved in profound debates arising both from the
emergence of new production and labour paradigms and the employment
market changes and from the persistence of groups and sectors
that are left out.
The Inter-American Centre for Knowledge Development
in Vocational Training (ILO/Cinterfor)
Avda. Uruguay 1238 - Montevideo - Uruguay - Tel: (5982) 908 6023 - 902 0557
- 908 0545 - Fax: (5982) 902 1305
webmaster@cinterfor.org.uy